We may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links

Top 6 Best Tool Box Drawer Liners in 2021 Review & Buying Guide

You’re on the job. You pull out your toolbox to grab the right tool and rummage through the drawers to find it. Problem is, all you hear is clanging, and your tools are all over the place.

Sound familiar?

If this is your life, we have the answer. You need liners. And not just any liners, like the pathetically thin cupboard liners in your kitchen. You need to get your hands on the best tool box drawer liners on the market.

Well, we got you. In this review, we’ll help you find what you need to keep your tools organized and scratch-free for years.

So, let’s get straight to it, starting with the…

Top 6 Best Tool Box Drawer Liners of 2021 Reviews

  1. B&C Home Goods – Best Budget Tool Box Drawer Liner
  2. Precision Defined Heavy Duty Tool Box Liner – Best Polyurethane Tool Box Drawer Liner
  3. Olsatools Tool Box Liner – Best PVC Foam Tool Box Drawer Liner
  4. Reizen Tech Max-Tough Tool Box Liner – Best Value for the Money Tool Box Drawer Liner
  5. Xcel Rubber Heavy Duty Tool Box Drawer Liner – Best Thick and Durable Tool Box Drawer Liner
  6. Lodesol Flexible Magnetic Tool Holder – Best Magnetic Tool Box Drawer Liner

1 B&C Home Goods – Best Budget Tool Box Drawer Liner

Dimensions: 18″ x 24 foot long roll

We’re going to start, as we like to do, with the cheapest product on our list. Then we’ll work up to the priciest and see how they compare. After all, who wants to pay more for something of the same or even lesser quality?

So the first toolbox liner we have is from B&C Goods. They call this The Toughest Toolbox Liner, but is it just a name, or can they back it up? Well, at about $1.40 per linear foot, it’s good value for one of the best cheap tool box drawer liners available.

Let’s get rolling…

This 24-foot long roll is going to give you lining for a whole of drawers. It’s made from 3/32-inch thick (3mm) tough, non-slip black foam rubber. This material offers natural protection from wear and tear.

We tried to scratch it lightly, then heavily with a sharp screwdriver to simulate what could happen in your tool chest. It held up pretty well. This liner is sturdy and lays flat right off the roll, so you won’t have to worry about it buckling or deforming. Just slap it down and cut the size you need off the roll.

There’s a sort of grid-like pattern on the surface, which helps it to grip your drawers and stay put. These gridlines can also help you to cut so long as they’re straight. The lines weren’t always at 90 degrees along our whole 24-foot roll.

More great value…

This liner is waterproof and spillproof. However, we found that some tools did stick to it a bit, especially those with vinyl handles. We suspect that in hotter conditions, this sticking might get even worse. So we wouldn’t recommend it out in the sun, like in your truck’s toolbox.

At the same time, it’s cheap, durable, and thick enough to protect your tools. And it’s one of the best affordable waterproof tool box drawer liners out there. That’s a good start.


B&C Home Goods

Our rating:4.8 out of 5 stars (4.8 / 5)

Pros

  • Inexpensive.
  • Stays in place.
  • Scratch-resistant.

Cons

  • Some tools may stick to the surface.

2 Precision Defined Heavy Duty Tool Box Liner – Best Polyurethane Tool Box Drawer Liner

Dimensions: 18″ x 24 foot long roll

Precision Defined is a great name, isn’t it? Makes us think of perfect products. Well, is this Heavy Duty Tool Box Liner one of those?

Very similar…

Next in our Best Liners for Tool Box review, this liner is just a couple of bucks more for the roll than the B&C we just saw. It’s the same size, both in width, length, and thickness. Yep, that’s 3/32 inches (3mm) thick. In this case, it’s made from tough, durable, black polyurethane foam. Well, wouldn’t you know it, this is the same thing as foam rubber, just with a different name.

The material is very similar to the B&W liner in that it’s soft but offers some resistance. It grips well and keeps your tools in place, and doesn’t slide around inside your drawers. Plus, it lays flat right off the roll and is easy to cut with a box cutter, razor, or even just sharp scissors. It seems to be at least somewhat oil resistant and is waterproof.

However, precise it’s not…

While the manufacturer claims the textured grid lines help you cut straight, these aren’t very useful unless you’re cutting an angle. The lines on the roll we got were on a 20-degree bias to the length and width of the roll. What’s more, the roll we got wasn’t a full 18 inches in width. It was almost half an inch shy.

Come on, guys! With a name like Precision Defined, we’re sure you should be able to do better.


Precision Defined Heavy Duty Tool Box Liner

Our rating:4.7 out of 5 stars (4.7 / 5)

Pros

  • Inexpensive.
  • Grips tools well and doesn’t slip in your drawers.

Cons

  • Gridlines aren’t straight to help with cutting the roll.
  • The dimensions are not accurate – the width of the roll was less than 18”.

3 Olsatools Tool Box Liner – Best PVC Foam Tool Box Drawer Liner

Dimensions: 18″ x 24 foot long roll

In case you think you’re seeing the same product all over again, look closer. Yes, Olsatools is giving us an 18-inch wide, 24-foot long roll of foamy liner for almost the same price as Precision Defined’s product.

But in this case, the liner is a little bit thicker at 1/8″ (3.2mm). It’s also a textured, perforated sheet rather than a solid one. Instead of PU or foam rubber, this liner is made from PVC foam. As a result, it’s one of the best lightweight tool box drawer liners available.

What’s PVC foam?

If you’ve ever slept on a camp roll, you’re probably familiar with PVC foam. We fund this type of liner to be less scratch-resistant. Because it’s perforated, sharp tools or things with hooks can get caught on the holes and tear them. And because of those holes, this liner isn’t going to protect your tool chest drawers from spills of water, oil, or chemicals.

On the other hand…

The extra thickness and the holes give it a good softness and a good grip on both your drawer and your tools. It features a slightly tacky surface that helps to keep your tools in place well. If you don’t work with fluids and don’t have to worry about spills or sharp tools, this might be a good option.


Olsatools Tool Box Liner

Our rating:4.8 out of 5 stars (4.8 / 5)

Pros

  • Inexpensive.
  • Lightweight, in case you need to use a lot of it.
  • Gives a good grip on tools and drawers alike.

Cons

  • Can get snagged on sharp or hooked tools or parts.
  • Not water or other liquid proof.

4 Reizen Tech Max-Tough Tool Box Liner – Best Value for the Money Tool Box Drawer Liner

Dimensions: 18″ x 24-foot long roll

Now, we know you’re not going to get this liner mixed up with any of the others in this review. Reizen Tech has done something very different with their Max-Tough Tool Box Liner. And it’s obvious what that is.

While the competition has stuck to the classic black or grey serious colors for their toolbox liners, these guys have gone out on a limb. They’ve made their foam rubber liner in a bright, almost pinkish red or bright blue, depending on your preference.

Is this a major selling point?

Well, surprisingly, it might be. Not everyone uses shiny chromed tools that stand out just fine against a black background. And not everyone can see perfectly. Some handy folks out there will like the brightness this liner gives because it provides a great contrast to your tools. Unless your tools are all pink, that is?

Again, this is a 3/32-inch (3mm) thick foam rubber with a waffled texture to help it grip. And grip it does. We think this is one of the best grip tool box drawer liners you can buy. The grip might be a bit too good. We found that it stuck to some tools, especially in hot conditions. Again, you wouldn’t want that in a truck tool kit or anywhere else with high heat.

Everything in its place…

It lies flat out of the box, like the other brands. We found that heavy tools will make a slight imprint which can be a good thing when you want to re-organize and put everything back in its place.


Reizen Tech Max-Tough Tool Box Liner

Our rating:4.7 out of 5 stars (4.7 / 5)

Pros

  • Best grip for PU foam liner.
  • Bold colors give great contrast to help you find your tools easily.

Cons

  • Can stick to tools in hot conditions.
  • A little more expensive than other brands.

5 Xcel Rubber Heavy Duty Tool Box Drawer Liner – Best Thick and Durable Tool Box Drawer Liner

Dimensions: 17″ x 6-foot long roll

Wait, did you just read that right? Sure did. We’ve suddenly moved from those long bulk rolls of liner to a product that’s sold in a much smaller size. And remember how we said we’d move from cheapest to most expensive in this review? Well, we are.

While 6 feet of Xcel Rubber’s Heavy Duty Tool Box Drawer Liner costs less than all the products we’ve seen so far, that’s the roll cost. By the linear foot, this liner costs way more than double what the other liners do.

Why is that?

This is a top-of-the-line product that’s thicker and more durable than the others. It’s ¼” (6.35mm) thick versus the 3/32” other products. Yes, that’s more than double the thickness.

This liner is made from black closed-cell neoprene foam. It’s one of the most durable toolbox drawer liners around. Furthermore, it’s also one of the best scratch resistant tool box drawer liners on the market. And more or less waterproof.

Quality all around…

The manufacturer throws some numbers at us. This foam has a density of 7-9 PCF and a tensile strength of 50 PSI. Sounds good, but no one else gave us their stats to compare with.

We do know that it’s American-made. And produced from post-consumer materials for a more environmentally friendly product. It lies flat in tool kit drawers. The grip for tools is solid, and it’s heavy enough not to move around at all.

Give it an airing…

One issue about this liner is that it has a strong chemical smell from the factory. You might want to air it out for a night before cutting it to size and installing it in your toolbox.


 Xcel Rubber Heavy Duty Tool Box Drawer Liner

Our rating:4.2 out of 5 stars (4.2 / 5)

Pros

  • Thick and durable.
  • Grips tools well.

Cons

  • Expensive.
  • Initially has a bad smell.

6 Lodesol Flexible Magnetic Tool Holder – Best Magnetic Tool Box Drawer Liner

Dimensions: 9.5” x 22.38” sheet

Next up in our Best Tool Box Drawer Liners review, it’s time for something completely different. So far, we have looked at products that are all pretty similar. They’ve been made of similar materials with similar dimensions and priced around the same ballpark, except for the last one. Well, Lodesol has come up with a completely different sort of toolbox drawer liner to show you.

What’s it all about?

Rather than relying on a textured foam mat and gravity to keep your tools in place, this new product uses magnets. Yep, magnets. As you will see, it’s one of the most versatile tool box drawer liners currently on sale.

This mat is made from 1/3-inch thick vinyl with magnets embedded in it. They’re laid out with six rows of 15 larger magnets and five rows of 14 smaller magnets between them. This covers the whole mat with magnetic attraction to grip onto both your toolbox drawers and your tools.

Well, of course, they have to be made from steel…

Imagine you have a huge selection of hex drivers, drill bits, or wrenches. Everything will go and stay exactly where you want it because of these magnets.

The size of this mat, 9” x 22.38”, seems weird, but it will actually fit very well into most 26″ wide tool chests. The vinyl sheeting is chemical and abrasion-resistant, as well as resistant to oil, gasoline brake fluid, and other chemicals.

Mix and match…

The price of this liner is way higher than the rest, so you might not want to line your whole tool chest with it. Instead, you could mix this magnetic liner with another product, and use it just for the small, finicky bits you need to keep organized.


Lodesol Flexible Magnetic Tool Holder

Our rating:4.7 out of 5 stars (4.7 / 5)

Pros

  • Magnets hold everything in place perfectly.
  • Mat is scratch resistant and durable.

Cons

  • Very expensive.
  • Comes only in small, set sizes that can’t be trimmed to size.

Best Tool Box Drawer Liners Buying Guide

Best Tool Box Drawer Liners Buying Guide

There’s nothing worse than tools getting lost in the back of a drawer when you need them the most. Maybe there is. How about your good tools getting scratched, chipped, and dented as they clang around in an un-lined toolbox drawer?

Well, no more. We’re here to help you find the best drawer liners to suit your needs and budget. Here are some of the main factors to think about when making your choice.

Material

Most of the best toolbox drawer liners are made from synthetic foams, including foam rubber (PU foam), vinyl, and PVC foam. Each of these materials has its own properties. Foam rubber is soft and supple, giving a very good rest for tools and parts. It can, however, degrade in high temperatures. And if it does, it could stick onto your tools and cause your liner to fail.

PVC and vinyl handle heat much better. So they’re both a good choice if you work in a sweatbox. If you’re looking to put liners in your truck’s toolbox, it will catch a lot of sun, so consider PVC.

Both of these foams give a good grip to both tools and drawers. But if you want a magically perfect drawer, magnets might be the answer. Magnetic drawer liners help to keep everything perfectly in place. They can cost a pretty penny, though.

Resistance

Toolbox drawer liners need to stand up to a fair bit of abuse. If you’re a mechanic, your tools are going to get fluids on them like gasoline, motor oil, and brake fluid. Other trades have their share of chemicals that can damage both liners and drawers.

But considering the price of liners, you want them to at least protect your drawers from any spills. They should be leakproof and stand up to the common fluids that you’ll run into in your line of work.

Scratch resistance

Scratches from sharp tools and parts can damage your liners. So you want to look for a material that has a good level of scratch resistance. You also don’t want it to tear in case you pull a tool out, and it somehow snags the liner.

On the other hand, you want a liner that is easy to cut and install. That way, you don’t waste time and money sizing things up over and over again.

Price

Finally, but probably most importantly, comes the price. Think about how many drawers you need to line and calculate the linear feet you’re going to need. If you need a lot for a large, multi-drawer toolbox, then you’re probably best getting a cheaper, larger roll. If you just need to line a few drawers, maybe you want to splurge on the expensive stuff.

But there are also combinations. You can always line a few of your most important drawers with a high-quality liner, then go cheaper for drawers that house tools that don’t need as much protection.

Looking for Something Else?

We have all kinds of garage and workshop accessories. Check out our in-depth reviews of the Best Magnetic Tool Holders, the Best Tool Chests, the Best Garage Floor Mats, the Best Socket Organizer, the Best Garage Door Lubricant, and the Best Air Impact Wrench you can buy in 2021.

Also, have a look at our comprehensive reviews of the Best Kinetic Recovery Rope, the Best Trailer Hitch Locks, the Best Vehicle Lifts for Home Garages, the Best Car Battery Charger, or the Best Garage Door Opener currently on the market.

What are the Best Tool Box Drawer Liners?

In this review, we looked at some of the best drawer liners for toolboxes available. They ranged in price from quite cheap to super expensive. But we think the average person doesn’t need magnets or super-thick foam for all applications.

So long as you’re lining a toolbox under regular conditions and not the blazing sun, we’d like to recommend the…

Reizen Tech Max-Tough Tool Box Line

It’s a bit more expensive than some of its rivals, but it grips tools well. And the color contrast it gives helps you find tools and quickly and easily. That’s our favorite, but maybe you found one of your own. In any case, enjoy the wonderful world of tools that stay put.

Until next time, may your DIYs make you smile.

Share:

Leave a Comment